TripBase Logo
Carnival Cruise Line

Carnival Magic

Dream-class cruise ship · flagged in Panama. Browse upcoming sailings and route previews for this ship.

Image via Wikimedia Commons
Tonnage
130,000
Capacity
3,690
Built
2,011
Length
306 m
Upcoming
74

Reviewer read

A solid, middle-of-the-fleet ship. It falls behind on disembarkation.

Carnival Magic rates higher overall than 63% of the ships we track. Activities is its strongest showing. The weak spot is disembarkation.

Why reviewers choose it

  • Activities8.1

    Higher than 65% of ships · 2,793 ratings

  • Entertainment7.8

    Higher than 63% of ships · 4,374 ratings

  • Fitness7.5

    Higher than 61% of ships · 1,077 ratings

  • Service8.7

    Higher than 51% of ships · 4,506 ratings

The one caution

8.3out of 10 for disembarkation

Higher than only 18% of ships. The typical ship scores 8.80.

Everything else, in two lines

Six are good without being remarkable: activities, entertainment, fitness, value, cabins and service. They rate higher than 51% to 65% of ships.

Five fall below the fleet: dining, embarkation, public areas, ship quality and disembarkation. They rate higher than 18% to 47% of ships.

Family falls below the fleet too, but only 45 people scored it, so treat it as a hint.

Cabin grade barely matters here. The inside, oceanview, balcony and suite grades all score between 8.29 and 8.54. Pick on price and position, not on rating.

Three places worth knowing about

  • Lido deck The one people argue about57% positive · 113 comments
  • Red Frog Pub The bar people mention most87% positive · 132 comments
  • Guys Burgers Also well liked83% positive · 119 comments

Reviewers named 12 places by name. These 3 are the ones where knowing changes anything — the other 7 are all liked by 65% to 87% of the people who mentioned them.

Who says it suited them

First-time cruisers (314 of 341), families with young kids (194 of 253), families with teens (81 of 101), couples (53 of 61), large groups (38 of 41) and solo travelers (18 of 26).

No group described it as a poor fit.

What we can’t tell you

How it suits older travelers
Too few reviewers on this ship described traveling as seniors.
How it handles mobility needs
Too few reviewers mentioned accessibility here.
Whether it's good value today
Reviews describe the fare people paid, not the one you'll be quoted.

Every category, compared

The mark on each bar is where the typical ship sits.

CategoryRatingCompared with other shipsEvidence
Service8.7Higher than 51%4,506 ratings · broad
Ship quality8.5Higher than only 34%3,230 ratings · broad
Cabins8.4Higher than 51%4,639 ratings · broad
Embarkation8.4Higher than only 44%3,272 ratings · broad
Disembarkation8.3Higher than only 18%1,999 ratings · broad
Activities8.1Higher than 65%2,793 ratings · broad
Entertainment7.8Higher than 63%4,374 ratings · broad
Dining7.8Higher than only 47%4,547 ratings · broad
Public areas7.6Higher than only 36%1,258 ratings · broad
Fitness7.5Higher than 61%1,077 ratings · broad
Value7.0Higher than 51%1,226 ratings · broad
Family6.9Higher than only 49%45 ratings · limited

5,259 published reviews · 392 from the last three years · 35,260 individual comments read.

On the chart

Upcoming sailings on Carnival Magic